Federal Employee Wealth Center
Traditional vs. Roth Education Calculator
See how the timing of income tax changes after-tax results, using illustrative tax assumptions you choose. Neither option is universally better.
Read: Traditional vs. Roth TSPTraditional TSP
- Goes into the TSP each year
- $6,000
- Lowers your take-home pay by about
- $4,680
- Illustrative balance
- $346,497
- Tax due on withdrawal
- − $76,229
Illustrative after-tax value
$270,268
Roth TSP
- Goes into the TSP each year
- $4,680
- Lowers your take-home pay by about
- $4,680
- Illustrative balance
- $270,268
- Tax due on qualified withdrawal
- $0
Illustrative after-tax value
$270,268
Under these assumptions, the after-tax results are about the same. When the tax rate today equals the tax rate in retirement, Traditional and Roth come out even at the same take-home cost.
| If your retirement tax rate is | Traditional, after tax | Roth, after tax |
|---|---|---|
| Lower in retirement (12%) | $304,917 | $270,268 |
| Same in retirement (22%) | $270,268 | $270,268 |
| Higher in retirement (32%) | $235,618 | $270,268 |
Other differences the math above does not capture
- Both share one elective deferral limit ($24,500 in 2026). A Roth dollar is after tax, so a maxed-out Roth contribution shelters more total value.
- Agency contributions are always Traditional, so FERS employees have some Traditional money either way.
- Roth withdrawals are tax-free only if qualified: 5 years since your first Roth contribution and age 59½, disability, or death.
- Roth TSP balances have no required minimum distributions during your lifetime (since 2024). Traditional balances generally do, starting at 73 (75 if born in 1960 or later).
- Traditional contributions lower taxable income today, which can affect credits and deductions.
Assumptions and limitations
- Traditional and Roth are compared at the same take-home cost: the Roth contribution equals the Traditional contribution minus the tax it saves today.
- Uses one flat marginal tax rate today and one flat rate on all withdrawals. Real tax situations are progressive, change over time, and depend on your other income.
- Assumes Roth withdrawals are qualified, and ignores state-specific rules, the IRS 10% additional tax, fees, and investing the Traditional tax savings elsewhere.
- Uses a constant hypothetical return. Real returns vary and can be negative.
- Educational illustration only. It does not recommend Traditional or Roth. Consider a qualified tax professional for your situation.
Official sources
- TSP: Traditional and Roth contributions (opens in a new tab)
- TSP: Contribution limits (opens in a new tab)
- IRS: Required minimum distributions (opens in a new tab)
Rules last reviewed November 1, 2026. Always confirm current rules with the official source.
Your federal benefits are part of your wealth.
Take the free TSP Checkup, or explore the calculators. No account details, ever.